About the Tree - a symbol of what?

First Christmas is a Christian Holiday - and while the tree is originally pagan... the times make it a Christmas symbol.

Back to the question: Is it appropriate to take a symbol from a different faith and rationalize it as Jewish?

Well some traditions in Reform Judaism come from Christianity - the Confirmation service comes to mind as one.

But on the other hand, if I saw a beautiful decorative cross that I liked, I would not wear it or put it in my home because it sends the wrong message. The "cross" is clearly a Christian symbol, no doubts.

There are many opinions about Jews having trees and we only touched on a few of the arguments at class today.

Here are a few interesting links to opinions on the subject:

Case History for Having a Tree


Hanukkah Bush?

What Jews Do On Christmas
It is a good time for Jews to be good citizens and strengthen the bond with our Christian neighbors

The Jewish Christmas